Novocaine
Directed by David Atkins
Starring Steve Martin, Laura Dern, Helena Bonham Carter and Elias Koteas
MPAA: R
Grade: C-
I really wanted to like Novocaine. It had all of the elements necessary to grab my attention: drug addiction, quirky casting (Steve Martin, Elias Koteas and Laura Dern), horrific murder, and just to seal the deal they even tossed in Helena Bonham Carter dressing and behaving like Marla from Fight Club. Nice.
Should have been enough. Wasn't enough. Here's why. Novocaine tells the story of Dr. Frank Sangster played by Steve Martin. He has a successful dentistry practice and a perfect fiancee (Laura Dern) who is also his assistant. He thinks he has it all. Frank's brother Harlan is a lifelong screw up, and he comes to stay with the good Dr. Frank for a bit. Frank seems to be noticing just how normal his life is when he encounters Susan Ivey (Helena Bonham Carter), a beautiful patient that puts the move on him. Dr. Frank falls for the tequila drinking, fishnet wearning, pill popping Susan. Bad move for Dr. Frank. Before long his whole world starts to unravel.
You get the sense that this was intended to be a dark film noir? I think so too, especially since they use a first person voice over throughout, similar to the best private eye films out there. You know the kind: "She sauntered into my office and I just knew by the way she lit her cigarette that entire life would soon turn upside down." Well, those kind of voice-overs are hard to pull off, and if you are going that route, you'd better pull out all the stops. Keep it dark, keep it murky and keep the characters right on track.
Instead, Novocaine features some characters that reach for dark comedy, especially Laura Dern as the anal retentive Jean Noble and Elias Koteas as the sloppy yet scheming Harlan. They both play their characters over the top here and it just doesn't work right. Steve Martin does his best to walk the fine line between thriller and dark comedy here, but he never seems to bust through. Helena Bonham Carter is fantastic as the drug addicted troublemaker Susan Ivey, and she adds excitement and a shred of credibility to the scenes that she tries to save.
David Atkins (the director and writer of Novocaine) wrote the script for the excellent movie "Arizona Dream" starring Johnny Depp and Faye Dunaway. That movie also walked the fine line between comedy and drama. The splintered characterizations in Arizona Dream worked because the film was an artistic play on memories, love and fate - a splintered story looking back upon itself. But this type of layered characterizations does not work in Novociane. This is supposed to be a thriller, a mystery, a film-noir. Attempting subtle comedy in this script just didn't work and it detracts from what is really a decent plot. Novocaine, a movie that tries to be both mystery and comedy,is ultimately a film that will leave you disappointed.
Buy Novocaine On DVD From Amazon.com